Search form

Sections

Requiem for a Column: The Healthy Skeptic

Requiem for a Column: The Healthy Skeptic

After nearly six years, the Los Angeles Times has dropped my Healthy Skeptic column. I'm not surprised. I'm just amazed-and grateful-that it lasted so long.

The column-freelanced from my home in Billings, Montana-took a scientific look at brand-name health products, often with unflattering results. At a time when newspapers are hemorrhaging ad revenue, taking a critical look at Nestle or Swanson Vitamins probably wasn't a solid business move. But my editor Rosie Mestel supported me from the very start, and we plowed ahead, through good products and bad.

The approach was simple. I would find a health product that made bold or interesting claims. No shortage of those. Then I would interview at least two independent experts who could shed light on those claims. When possible, I'd also check the medical literature. (Some products-ionic foot baths for one-were too goofy to have much presence on Medline.) I would also try to get comments from someone at the company, an often frustrating pursuit.

Some products easily passed the plausibility test. Probiotics really can prevent diarrhea, vitamins really can protect against macular degeneration, and a toothpaste containing a cocoa extract may really help strengthen teeth and prevent cavities.

But others never did show much promise. Experts laughed when I asked if pendants could shield against radiation or if Kinoki foot pads could really suck toxins through the soles of the feet. Detoxifying infrared saunas, electric ab belts, homeopathic cold remedies-lots of products never really got off the runway of reason.

Oh, I got feedback: Companies complained about "hatchet jobs" and "hit pieces." But my editor Rosie always had my back. Here's part of her response to a disgruntled skin care company: "Neither Chris nor the L.A. Times Health staff would have an interest in suppressing data so they could slam a product. We are actually interested in learning what products make sense to buy and which do not, and some of the products get favorable reviews. The name of the column-Healthy Skeptic-pretty much sums up its purpose, which is to approach consumer health claims with healthy skepticism, not credulousness on the one hand nor out-of-hand dismissal on the other." How great is that?

I also heard from some readers who questioned my approach. Why didn't I personally try more of the products or at least interview real customers? In fact, I did test-drive a few products. I really did wear a Kinoki foot pad overnight, I worked out (briefly) with a Shake Weight and, in one of my favorite columns, I wore a human pheromone, designed to attract the opposite sex, with thoroughly disappointing results.

As I told one reader, the Healthy Skeptic tried to take a scientific view, and a one-person test isn't scientific. I didn't have the resources to set up double-blind trials. But I think I was still able to find information that readers could really use, information that often wasn't available anywhere else. When expert opinion and the medical literature suggest that a product is making false promises-that's something worth knowing.

Ultimately, the column became a casualty of a newspaper reorganization. Such things happen. I want to thank Rosie-and later Karen Kaplan- for such excellent guidance and support. Thanks also to Gary Schwitzer and the other folks at HealthNewsReview.org for paying attention. And thanks to the many experts for their insights, opinions and yes, some good laughs.

Bogus health products can be funny-assuming everyone is in on the joke. But when people don't have enough information to protect themselves, worthless pills and gadgets can be truly dangerous. Although the column is gone, healthy skepticism is as important as ever.

Comments

Chris, what will you do next? Are you still going to write about health products?

I think it's time for you to syndicate, Chris! Newspapers might not be so interested, but what about KHN, or folks like me who can't pay yet, but if all of the state-based health news websites (CA, OR, GA, FL, soon, New England) could pool a little something, perhaps???

Leave A Comment

CONNECT WITH THE COMMUNITY

Member Activities

Madhavi Dandu's profile has been updated

Connect with Madhavi Dandu

Ezra David Romero has shared a fellowship project

Read it.

Brian Rinker's profile has been updated

Connect with Brian Rinker

Martha Rosenberg has shared a blog post

Read it.

William Heisel has shared a blog post

Read it.
More Member Activities

Follow Us

ReportingHealth

Reporting on Underserved Communities



How can journalists and foundations collaborate to deepen and improve reporting on underserved communities? Our USC Annenberg School of Journalism program in collaboration with The California Endowment, the Wyncote Foundation and Media Impact Funders, convened 75 leaders from both fields.

Read More »