The California Endowment Health Journalism Fellowships Blog

Watch Your Language: Presenting Domestic Violence in News Reports

October 5, 2009

The New York Times reported in September that domestic violence programs in the state of California have have been largely eliminated. The Domestic Violence Program's last $16 million was cut completely in July, in efforts to close a near $24 billion state budget deficit.

Violence is a public health problem, said Eve F. Sheedy, Deputy City Attorney, Domestic Violence Legislative and Policy Advisor in the Los Angeles City Attorney's Office. It matters to public health that these resources have been cut.

While money is short, there are still ways to increase awareness and help victims of domestic violence. Sheedy made an appeal to the National Health Journalism Fellows to make some adjustments to the conventions of reporting on domestic violence. Here are some of her take-home points:

  • Journalists have no problem calling gangs using guns violence, but hesitate when it comes to the domestic realm. "Please never use the word 'domestic dispute.' A dispute is not putting the toilet seat down or not putting the cap back on toothpaste. When you write about domestic violence, call it domestic violence," Sheedy said. If a wife kills her husband or a husband kills his wife, this is violence. If a man beats his ex-girlfriend, it is domestic violence.
  • Avoid sentences like, "The children were upstairs and unharmed." "All children are harmed when they witness domestic violence," said Sheedy. Even if they escape physical harm, they are certainly not unharmed.
  • "If you choke, that is when something is stuck in your throat." People do not use the word 'strangulation.' Strangulation can kill in a matter of minutes and can have long-lasting damage for survivors. That word makes people react differently than the word 'choke.'
  • Be careful about naming and showing victims of domestic violence. They are often still in danger.
  • The passive voice: the phrase "The woman was raped," for example, takes the responsibility away from rapists. It does not make explicit that the victim is not at fault for what happened. "Focus responsibility to the person responsible," Sheedy said. "The rapist is unknown," appropriately places emphasis on the perpetrator. "The reason the passive voice sounds right is because it is familiar," said Sheedy.
  • "Domestic violence is not rage and it's not anger and it's not I've lost my job and I'm upset." Stress, poverty and mental health does not cause domestic violence. All of these things can play a role, but pinning down a single cause undercuts the complexity and breadth of the problem.
  • Domestic violence happens in rich neighborhoods and poor neighborhoods, even if wealthy people have the ability to avoid police and emergency rooms.
  • "It is extremely rare for someone to come home one day and all of a sudden commit a violent act." If a man runs down his children and neighbors say he was an incredibly attentive father, ask follow-up questions. Was he controlling? Were there incidents before the murder?
  • When you write a story that arises from domestic violence, include a sentence about hotline numbers people can call. "It would be a tremendous public service if you can help us get the word out." The number is 1-800-799-SAFE.
COMMENTS | login or register to post comments
Angilee Shah

Sheedy's comments about the danger of pinpointing causes for domestic violence raised some questions about the possibility of intervention. Alex Morales, the Children's Bureau president and CEO, commented that violence against women and children in particular has been fed by tolerance, by social norms. But communities in the neighborhoods around Magnolia Place have extra pressures that promote domestic violence.

"The stresses of the neighborhoods around Magnolia Place -- unemployment and underemployment, lack of social justice -- can be overbearing for people and can feed into violence," said Morales. How children are treated under these stressful conditions is important for their development and ability to manage their feelings as well. Because of the economics, housing is crowded and outdoor or recreational space is rare, further feeding stressful conditions. Programs that address these problems can help reduce violence. One of the goals of Magnolia Place is to create nurturing family settings.

LEAVE A COMMENT

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
 

Editor Picks

Seth Mnookin on Chicago Sun-Times-Jenny McCarthy "propaganda piece"

Why on earth is the Chicago Sun-Times "proudly" supporting Jenny McCarthy's anti-vaccine autism conference? more »

| Wed, 05/16/12 01:59pm

MORE:

Daily Briefing: "Product Non Grata": Public Health Officials Delight in Dropping Soda Sales

Obamacare myths that won't die, TB patient arrested, and what's behind a recent drop in soda sales, plus more from our Daily Briefing. more »
By Barbara Feder Ostrov | Wed, 05/16/12 10:31am

Editing Health Stories

Karen Weintraub, a former editor at The Boston Globe, offers tips for editing health and science stories — and deciding what not to cover. more »
posted by Karen Weintraub | Tue, 10/26/10 02:15pm | 2 comments

The Latest From Our Community

Mother's love inspires immediate, permanent relief from pain

A mother’s love is a powerful thing; powerful enough to provide immediate, and permanent, relief from pain. more »
posted by Eric Nelson | Wed, 05/16/12 11:49am

Finding My Way Through the Fitness Deserts

What I've learned writing my fitness deserts series for The Washington Post Express. more »
posted by Vicky Hallett | Tue, 05/15/12 04:01pm

A Renewed Focus on Alzheimer's Dementia

Pills prices, agricultural antibiotics, Medicare politics, fracking and more from our Daily Briefing. more »
posted by Nathanael Johnson | Tue, 05/15/12 07:08am

Data Reporting E-book - Download.

What makes your community healthy or unhealthy? Use our step-by-step data reporting guide to uncover untold stories!

Learn More >

Member Activities

Seth Mnookin has shared a blog post

Barbara Feder Ostrov has shared a blog post

Eric Nelson has shared a blog post

Michelle Gordon joined the community

Connie Ho joined the community

Log in to connect with the community.

Facebook

Twitter

    Recent Comments

    • Kay S. Rose on How We Do Harm: Otis...

      I totally agree on the issue of rational treatment based on science and know effectiveness... more »

      05/16/12 04:58am

    • Introducing a wealth of ideas for new online health-related on Matter: How A Sci...

      [...] in pursuing any of these concepts, there may be some inspiration in this Reporting... more »

      05/16/12 02:11am

    • Cheryl Truman on Talk to Us! Health...

      Kudos to you, Katherine. I once had an editor who told me that the whole... more »

      05/15/12 01:19pm

    • Stacy on Why Michele Simon is...

      Actually, the point of the documentary was to point out that collective action is needed... more »

      05/15/12 10:19am

    • Tony Litterio on Eliminating the...

      Greg: What are mega-doses of fatty acid Omega3?-how much? Can I find them in normal... more »

      05/15/12 07:58am


    Contact Us  |   About Us  |   USC Annenberg  |   Our Funder  |   Advisory Board  |   FAQ  |   Feedback  |   Privacy Policy  |   Terms of Use
    A project supported by The California Endowment